In this article
- Salary expectations and salary negotiation are not the same moment
- Step 1: Research the range before you name a number
- Step 2: Set your three numbers
- Step 3: Build your case in writing
- What to say when you are asked about salary expectations
- Step 4: Respond to the offer, step by step
- A counteroffer you can copy
- If the base pay cannot move, negotiate the rest
- Negotiating hourly and entry-level pay: the honest version
- Asking for a raise in a job you already have
- Know your rights before you negotiate
- Mistakes that cost people money
- If they say no
- Get the final offer in writing: the checklist
- FAQ
- About the author
You negotiate salary in the few days between getting an offer and accepting it, and those few days can set your pay for years. The work is not complicated. Research the pay range for the job in your area using free official data. Set the lowest number you can accept before anyone asks. Build a short case based on the work itself. Then make one clear, polite counteroffer, and get the final agreement in writing.
None of that requires being pushy. Employers who make offers expect a conversation about pay. What they do not respond well to is a number with nothing behind it, which is why most of this guide is about preparation. The talking part is short. The homework is the negotiation.
Salary expectations and salary negotiation are not the same moment
Pay comes up twice in a hiring process, and mixing the two moments up is where many people lose money.
The first moment is early, often in the first call or interview, when you are asked about your salary expectations. At that point you know little about the role, and the employer has not decided they want you. Naming a precise figure here can only box you in. The goal at this stage is to keep the conversation open, which our interview questions guide covers in its salary section.
The second moment is real negotiation, and it starts when you have an actual offer. Now the employer has chosen you over other candidates, the duties are clear, and there is a written number to discuss. This is the strongest position you will be in, and it is the moment this guide is built around.
Step 1: Research the range before you name a number
A negotiation without a researched range is just a wish. You need to know what the job pays in your area, for your level, before you can tell whether an offer is fair, low, or strong. Two free official sources do most of this work.
The BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook (bls.gov/ooh). The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes a page for hundreds of occupations, with the national median pay, what the lowest-paid and highest-paid 10 percent earned, and the typical entry education. Find the occupation closest to the job you were offered and note the median and the bottom band.
CareerOneStop’s Salary Finder (careeronestop.org). This tool, sponsored by the U.S. Department of Labor, shows low, median, and high pay for about 800 occupations, and you can look at your state or region instead of only the nation. Its wage data comes from the BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics program and was updated in June 2026 with May 2025 estimates. Local figures matter, because the same job pays differently in different labour markets.
The employer’s own posted range. A growing number of states require employers to put a pay range in the job posting, and many employers elsewhere post one anyway. If the posting for your job carried a range, that range is the employer’s own statement of what the role is worth. Keep a copy of it.
Read the figures honestly. A median is the middle of all workers in that occupation, across every experience level. It is not a starting salary, and beginners usually start below it, nearer the bottom band. The BLS figure for all full-time workers combined, a median of $1,204 a week in 2025, shows why a single national number is useless for your decision: your occupation and your area are what count, not the national average across every job in the country.
Write down three figures from your research: the low end for your area and level, the median, and the pay of experienced workers in the same occupation. Your negotiation will live inside that range.
Step 2: Set your three numbers
Before you talk to anyone, decide three numbers and write them down.
Your floor. The lowest pay at which you would genuinely take the job and stay. Build it from your real costs and from the low end of your researched range, not from hope. If an offer lands below this number and cannot move, the honest answer is no, and it is far easier to know that in advance than to work it out on a phone call.
Your target. The figure inside the researched range that fits your experience and the duties in the posting. This is the number your counteroffer aims at.
Your stretch. The top of what your research can support, for example the median or above it when your experience, a licence, or a hard-to-fill skill matches what the employer asked for. You may open near here if your case is strong.
One warning about anchors. Basing your numbers on what you earned in your last job is a trap, especially if that job underpaid you. Your previous pay says what a different employer paid for a different role. The researched range for this job, in this area, is the anchor that holds up in a conversation. In many states and cities, employers are also restricted from asking about your pay history at all, a point we return to in the rights section below.
Step 3: Build your case in writing
Employers do not raise offers because a candidate needs more money. Rent, bills, and a long commute are real pressures, but they are not arguments an employer can act on. Offers move when the case is about the job: skills that match the posting, experience that cuts training time, a certificate the role needs, flexibility the schedule needs.
Sit down with the job posting and list, line by line, where you match what it asks for. Add anything the posting treats as a plus that you actually have. Note the duties you have done before in the same form, because “has already done this exact task” is the strongest beginner argument there is. If your resume does not show this evidence clearly, fix that first. Our guide to skills to put on a resume walks through how to present skills with proof behind them.
Keep the case short. Three or four solid points you can say in under a minute, or write in a few lines, will do more than a long speech. Practise saying them out loud once or twice. The first time you hear your own counteroffer should not be on the call itself.
What to say when you are asked about salary expectations
This question usually arrives before any offer, and the safest answers either ask for the employer’s range or give your researched range, never a single exact figure pulled from your last payslip. These wordings work:
“Could you share the pay range budgeted for this role? I would like to make sure we are in the same area before we go further.”
“Based on my research for this kind of role in this area, I am looking at [your researched range]. I am flexible depending on the full package and the exact duties.”
“I would like to learn more about the role and the full benefits before settling on a number. Can we come back to pay once we both know it is a fit?”
If you are pressed for a number, give the range from your research, with the low end set at a figure you would actually accept. The low end of a range you name is the part employers hear most clearly, so never name a floor you would regret.
If you are asked what you earn now, you can redirect in the same way: “I would rather focus on the range for this role. My research puts it at [range], and that is what I am aiming at.” In many states and cities the employer is not permitted to ask about pay history in the first place. The rules differ by place, so check your state labour agency’s page if this comes up.
Step 4: Respond to the offer, step by step
When the offer arrives, the order of what you do matters more than any clever line.
1. Thank them, and show you want the job. Say plainly that you are pleased and excited about the role. Negotiation goes better when the employer is sure you want to join, and are discussing terms, not interest.
2. Ask for time to review it. Do not accept or counter on the spot. The New York State Department of Labor’s salary negotiation guide advises candidates not to accept an offer immediately, and gives 24 to 48 hours as a reasonable amount of time to ask for. Use that time. Read the full offer, including benefits, hours, and start date, not just the headline pay.
3. Compare the whole offer with your three numbers. Base pay is one part. Health coverage, paid time off, overtime, bonuses or commission terms, retirement plans, and the schedule all change what an offer is worth. The same state guide makes the same point: judge the entire benefits package, not the salary alone. Two offers with equal pay can be worth quite different amounts once these are counted.
4. Make one clear counteroffer. Pick the figure, state it once, give your case in a few lines, and stop. A counteroffer that keeps moving sounds like guessing. One number, backed by your research and your match for the role, sounds like a decision.
5. Let them respond. After you counter, wait. The employer may need to check a budget or get an approval, which can take a day or more. Silence after a counteroffer is normal process, not rejection.
A counteroffer you can copy
Adapt these to your own figures. The numbers in brackets come from your research in Step 1, not from this page.
By email:
Subject: [Your name] — offer for [job title]
Thank you for the offer to join [company] as a [job title]. I am excited about the role and the team, and I appreciate the offer of [$X].
Based on my research into pay for this role in [area], including Bureau of Labor Statistics data, and on my experience with [your strongest matching points, in one line], I was hoping we could agree on [$Y]. I am confident I can [one duty from the posting you can already do well], and I am ready to start on [date] if we can settle the pay.
Please let me know if that works, or if there is another part of the package where there is room to move.
Thank you again, [Your name]
On the phone, the same thing in spoken form:
“Thank you, I am really pleased, and I want to accept. Before I do, I want to discuss the starting pay. Your offer is [$X]. Based on the pay range for this work in [area] and my experience with [matching points], I was looking for [$Y]. Is there room to meet that?”
Then stop talking. The pause after a counteroffer feels long. Filling it by lowering your own number is the most common way people negotiate against themselves.
Why this is worth doing, in plain arithmetic. Take an example, with the assumption stated openly: two starting salaries of $52,000 and $57,000, each rising 3 percent a year, in the same job for ten years. The $52,000 start adds up to about $596,122 over those ten years. The $57,000 start adds up to about $653,441. The gap is about $57,319, from one conversation at the start. This is an example calculation, not a prediction. Your raises, your employer, and your career will differ. The point it makes is real, though: a starting figure is not a one-year figure, because later percentage raises build on it.
If the base pay cannot move, negotiate the rest
Sometimes the base figure genuinely is fixed by a pay band. That ends one conversation, not the whole negotiation. Depending on the job, these parts of a package can have room in them:
- A signing bonus, which covers a gap for the first year without changing the band
- An earlier first pay review, agreed in writing, instead of waiting for the standard annual cycle
- More paid time off, or a specific schedule or shift arrangement
- Training, a course, or a certification paid for by the employer
- A later start date, if you need time to finish a notice period properly
- The job title, where a stronger title supports your next move
- For hourly roles, the shift you are assigned to, since shift timing can change both your hours and any differential the employer pays
Ask about one or two of these, not the whole list. And if the employer agrees to any of them, they go into the written offer, as the checklist below covers.
Negotiating hourly and entry-level pay: the honest version
Much negotiation advice is written for senior salaried staff. If you are applying for hourly, retail, warehouse, care, or other entry-level work, the picture is different, and pretending otherwise would not help you.
Pay for many of these roles sits inside a set band, and the person hiring you may have little authority to move it. Government jobs and union roles often have fixed scales that do not move for anyone. In those cases the base rate is a take-it-or-leave-it figure, and your decision is whether the job, at that rate, beats your other options.
That does not make you powerless. Three things still matter. First, bands usually have a range, and where you land inside it can depend on the experience and certificates you show, so the case-building in Step 3 still counts. Second, the items in the section above, especially schedule, shift, start date, and a review date, are often open even when the rate is not. Third, knowing the local range from CareerOneStop tells you whether this employer’s band is fair for your area at all, which is the information you need before you accept. Current openings, with their employers, are listed on our find jobs page.
Asking for a raise in a job you already have
The method is the same, with one change: your case is your record in this job, not your match for a posting.
Research the range for your role in your area first, the same way as Step 1. Then list what has changed since your pay was last set: duties added, training completed, problems handled, results you can point to. Ask for a meeting about your pay rather than raising it in passing, state the figure your research supports, give your evidence, and ask what the process and timing are if it cannot happen at once. If the answer is no, ask what would need to be true for a yes at the next review, and note the answer. That turns a refusal into a target.
Know your rights before you negotiate
This section is general information, not legal advice. For a problem in your own workplace, your state labour agency or an employment lawyer is the right call.
You can discuss pay with coworkers. Under the National Labor Relations Act, employees covered by the Act have the right to talk with coworkers about their wages. The National Labor Relations Board states that policies which specifically prohibit discussing wages are unlawful, and that it is unlawful for an employer to punish or retaliate against a covered employee for having such a conversation. The Act does not cover everyone. Public-sector employees, supervisors, and independent contractors are among the groups outside it, and other laws may protect some of them instead.
Pay questions have legal limits in many places. Many states and cities restrict employers from asking about your salary history, and a growing number require a pay range in job postings or on request. The details vary a lot: which employers are covered, what must be disclosed, and when the rule took effect all differ by state, and some cities add their own rules. Before you rely on a specific rule, check the current page of the labour agency in the state where the job is based.
A posted range is information, use it. Where a range is published, the employer has told you the band the role sits in. Your research tells you where inside that band your experience should land. That is a firmer basis for a counteroffer than any guess.
Mistakes that cost people money
Naming a number before doing any research. A figure with no range behind it is hard to defend and harder to raise later.
Accepting on the spot. Excitement is understandable. It is also how people sign offers they have not read. Take the day or two the state guide describes as reasonable.
Negotiating against yourself. Countering, then lowering your own number because the reply is slow. Employers need time to check budgets. Wait for their answer.
Basing the case on personal costs. “My rent went up” is true for many people and moves no budgets. The case that works is about the role and what you bring to it.
Arguing from your old pay. Your last employer’s figure is not evidence of what this job pays in this area. Your research is.
Treating the first no as the end. A no on base pay can still leave the bonus, the review date, the schedule, or the training open, as the earlier section sets out.
Skipping the written offer. A verbal agreement that never reaches the offer letter is hard to rely on. The checklist below exists for this reason.
If they say no
A firm no on pay, delivered after they have checked, is an answer, not an insult. You have three honest options. Accept the offer as it stands, if it sits above your floor and the full package works. Ask whether another part of the package can move instead. Or decline politely, if it sits below the floor you set in Step 2, and keep the door open by thanking them for the process.
What not to do is accept while planning to resent the pay from week one. That helps nobody, and it usually ends in a second job search within months. Your floor exists so that this decision is made calmly, in advance, rather than under pressure.
One question people worry about is whether negotiating can cost them the offer. We will not dress this up: no guide can promise what a specific employer will do. What reduces the risk is the manner of it. A polite, researched, one-time counteroffer, from a candidate who has clearly said they want the job, is a normal part of hiring that employers deal with routinely. Threats, invented competing offers, and repeated rounds of demands are a different matter, and they are not what this guide recommends. Never claim another offer you do not have. If it is checked, or even suspected, your credibility is gone, and credibility is the asset the whole negotiation rests on.
Get the final offer in writing: the checklist
The New York State Department of Labor’s guide gives the same closing advice: get your offer in writing. Before you start, check that the written offer matches what was agreed:
- Job title and start date
- Base pay, and whether it is hourly or salaried
- Hours, schedule, and shift, if they were part of the discussion
- Any signing bonus, and when it is paid
- Paid time off agreed
- Any earlier review date that was promised
- Training or certification funding that was agreed
- Overtime, commission, or bonus terms, where they apply to the role
If something agreed is missing, ask for it to be added before you sign, while the conversation is still warm. This is a normal request, and it is much easier now than after your first payday.
FAQ
When is the right time to negotiate salary? After you have a real offer, and before you accept it. The early “salary expectations” question is a screening step, where a researched range or a request for the employer’s range is the right response. The offer stage is where you have the full details, the employer has chosen you, and a specific counteroffer makes sense.
What should I say when asked for my salary expectations? Ask for the employer’s range, or give the range your research supports, with the low end set at a figure you would accept. Avoid a single exact number early on, and avoid anchoring on your previous pay. Word-for-word examples are in the section above.
Can I negotiate salary for my first job? Yes, within limits that depend on the job. Some employers use fixed starting scales, especially government and union roles, and those do not move. Many others set a band with room inside it. Researching the local range first tells you which situation you are in, and schedule, start date, and review timing can be open even when the starting rate is fixed.
How much should I ask for above the offer? There is no honest universal percentage, and any guide that gives you one without knowing your research is guessing. Ask for a figure inside the range your research supports for your area and level: your target from Step 2. If the offer already sits at or above that target, the negotiation may be about the other parts of the package instead.
What if the employer says the offer is final? Take it at face value on base pay, and ask once whether another part of the package can move, such as a signing bonus, the review date, or paid time off. Then decide against the floor you set before the conversation. Accept it if the full package works, or decline politely if it does not.
Can I lose a job offer by negotiating? No guide can guarantee an individual employer’s reaction. A single polite counteroffer, backed by research and paired with a clear statement that you want the job, is a standard part of hiring. The behaviour that damages candidates is different: threats, demands repeated after a clear answer, and claiming competing offers that do not exist.
About the author
Tajammul Abbasi writes HirePath USA’s career guides. Our team builds each guide from primary sources, in this case the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the Department of Labor’s CareerOneStop, the National Labor Relations Board, and the New York State Department of Labor, and re-checks the figures and links when a guide is updated. Pay figures in this guide are national or programme-level reference points, not promises about any single employer’s offer.
